Parents who ask whether their baby’s HIE was preventable are usually told one of two things: that it was nobody’s fault, or nothing at all. Neither is an answer. The answer is in a specific set of documents that every hospital keeps and every family is entitled to, and an HIE lawyer and their experts read them in a predictable order. This guide walks through the seven findings they look for first, what each one means, and how to get the records yourself before you decide anything.
1. The fetal heart rate strip: what was seen, and when
Electronic fetal monitoring produces a continuous record of the baby’s heart rate against the mother’s contractions. Clinicians read it using three categories set out by the American College of Obstetricians and Gynecologists [1]: Category I is normal; Category II is indeterminate and calls for evaluation and continued surveillance; Category III, which includes absent variability with recurrent late or variable decelerations, or a sinusoidal pattern, is abnormal and requires prompt action, including preparation for delivery if it does not resolve. The strip shows the pattern. The nursing flow sheet beside it shows who looked at it, what they wrote, and whether the physician was called. Our guide to fetal heart rate monitoring categories explains the patterns in plain language.
2. The response: Pitocin, oxygen, position, and the call
When a tracing turns non-reassuring, the expected response is specific: stop or reduce Pitocin, reposition the mother, give oxygen and fluids, check for cord prolapse or bleeding, and notify the physician so that a decision about delivery can be made. The medication administration record shows when Pitocin was started, increased, held or stopped; the contraction channel of the strip shows whether contractions were too frequent for the baby to recover between them. Pitocin that was increased, or left running, through a deteriorating tracing is one of the most common findings in HIE cases. See Pitocin hyperstimulation and HIE and failures to recognize fetal distress.
3. Decision to incision: how long the cesarean took
When an emergency cesarean is called, the record contains two times that matter: the time the decision was documented, and the time of the first incision. The widely cited benchmark is 30 minutes, although the standard is that the interval must be as short as the situation requires, and a true emergency may demand faster. The anesthesia record and the operating room log fill in why a delay happened: no anesthesiologist in house, no operating room available, a surgeon who had to be called in. The delivery record then gives the time of birth, which anchors every later clock, including the six hours for cooling. See delayed C-section and HIE.
A free, confidential review of the records can tell you whether the care met the standard, at no cost to your family.
4. Cord blood gases and 5. Apgar scores and resuscitation
At delivery the cord can be clamped and sampled for arterial and venous blood gases. An umbilical artery pH below 7.0 or a base deficit of 12 mmol/L or more is one of the findings that the ACOG and AAP report lists as consistent with an acute intrapartum event [2]; normal gases argue the other way. The resuscitation record and the Apgar scores at one, five and ten minutes describe the baby’s condition and what was done: positive-pressure ventilation, intubation, chest compressions, epinephrine. A low score at five and ten minutes is another of the report’s criteria. The record also shows who was present. A high-risk delivery with no one trained in neonatal resuscitation in the room is a finding in itself. Our guides to cord blood gas and pH and Apgar scores explain the numbers.
6. The cooling timeline
Therapeutic hypothermia is the standard of care for eligible babies with moderate or severe HIE and must begin within six hours of birth [3]. The chart should contain a cooling eligibility assessment, usually on a standard form, with the gas results, the neurological exam and the decision. If the birth hospital does not cool, the record shows when the regional center was called, when the transport team arrived and when active cooling began. A baby who met the criteria and whose chart has no cooling assessment, or whose cooling began at seven hours after a slow transfer, has a second potential claim that is separate from the labor. See our guides to cooling eligibility and delayed or missed cooling.
7. The MRI: timing and pattern
The brain MRI, usually done between days three and seven, shows both where the injury is and roughly when it happened. Injury to the deep gray matter, the basal ganglia and thalamus, is the pattern associated with an acute, near-total lack of oxygen, as in a cord prolapse or abruption; injury in the watershed zones between arterial territories is associated with a partial, prolonged lack of oxygen, as in a long labor with a slowly deteriorating tracing [2]. Diffusion-weighted changes evolve over the first week, which lets neuroradiologists estimate timing and which is why the date of the scan matters. The placental pathology report, if a placenta was examined, adds whether the problem was acute or had been developing for days or weeks. Our guides to HIE MRI results, diffusion-weighted MRI and placental pathology go deeper.
Put together, the seven findings answer the two questions a claim has to answer: did the care fall below the standard, and did that failure cause the injury? They also answer the question families most want answered honestly: if the strip was reassuring until a sudden abruption, the cesarean began in nine minutes and cooling started at two hours of life, the records will say that nothing more could have been done, and a free review will tell you so [4]. See whether you can sue for HIE.
Step-by-step: what families can do now
None of these steps commits you to a claim. They keep every option open while you decide.
- Request the complete labor and delivery record, including the electronic fetal monitoring strips, from the birth hospital under HIPAA.
- Request the cesarean operative report and the anesthesia record, which contain the decision and incision times.
- Request the cord blood gas results, the resuscitation record and the Apgar scores.
- Request the cooling eligibility assessment and, if your baby was transferred, the transfer and transport records.
- Request the MRI images and reports and the placental pathology report, if one exists.
- Write a timeline of the delivery and the first days while details are fresh, then ask for a free, confidential review.
- Pennsylvania – birth injury deadlines, rules and courts
- New Jersey – birth injury deadlines, rules and courts
- Washington D.C. – birth injury deadlines, rules and courts
- Texas – birth injury deadlines, rules and courts
Show 35 more statesHide extra states
- Alabama – birth injury deadlines, rules and courts
- Arizona – birth injury deadlines, rules and courts
- Arkansas – birth injury deadlines, rules and courts
- California – birth injury deadlines, rules and courts
- Colorado – birth injury deadlines, rules and courts
- Connecticut – birth injury deadlines, rules and courts
- Florida – birth injury deadlines, rules and courts
- Georgia – birth injury deadlines, rules and courts
- Illinois – birth injury deadlines, rules and courts
- Indiana – birth injury deadlines, rules and courts
- Iowa – birth injury deadlines, rules and courts
- Kentucky – birth injury deadlines, rules and courts
- Maine – birth injury deadlines, rules and courts
- Maryland – birth injury deadlines, rules and courts
- Massachusetts – birth injury deadlines, rules and courts
- Michigan – birth injury deadlines, rules and courts
- Minnesota – birth injury deadlines, rules and courts
- Mississippi – birth injury deadlines, rules and courts
- Missouri – birth injury deadlines, rules and courts
- Montana – birth injury deadlines, rules and courts
- Nebraska – birth injury deadlines, rules and courts
- Nevada – birth injury deadlines, rules and courts
- New Hampshire – birth injury deadlines, rules and courts
- New Mexico – birth injury deadlines, rules and courts
- New York – birth injury deadlines, rules and courts
- Ohio – birth injury deadlines, rules and courts
- Oklahoma – birth injury deadlines, rules and courts
- Oregon – birth injury deadlines, rules and courts
- Rhode Island – birth injury deadlines, rules and courts
- Tennessee – birth injury deadlines, rules and courts
- Vermont – birth injury deadlines, rules and courts
- Washington – birth injury deadlines, rules and courts
- West Virginia – birth injury deadlines, rules and courts
- Wisconsin – birth injury deadlines, rules and courts
- Wyoming – birth injury deadlines, rules and courts
When to act quickly
Some deadlines run from the date of birth rather than from the diagnosis, wrongful death claims are usually shorter than an injured child’s claim, claims against public hospitals often require a written notice within months, and federal facilities follow the Federal Tort Claims Act with its own two-year administrative claim. Hospitals also follow records-retention schedules, so fetal monitoring strips and nursing records are easiest to obtain while they are recent. If any of these may apply to your family, ask now rather than later.
What to bring to a case review
Bring, or be ready to request, three things: the complete prenatal, labor and delivery and NICU records including the fetal monitoring strips; a written timeline of the delivery and the first days with the names you remember; and every discharge summary, imaging report, neurology note and therapy evaluation since. If a placenta was sent to pathology, ask for that report too. You do not need to organize or interpret any of it; that is the attorney’s job.
How CP Family Help supports families
CP Family Help is not a law firm. We are an informational resource and free case-review service, sponsored by Villari, Giannone & Matteo, P.C., that helps families in 38 states and Washington, D.C. understand what may have happened and connects them with experienced birth injury trial attorneys when they want to explore a claim. Intake is available in English and Spanish, the review is free and confidential, and partner attorneys work on a written contingency agreement, so there are no upfront fees and no fee unless there is a recovery. If the records show that nothing could have been done, you will be told so plainly.
Independent experts, not the hospital, read the records. Ask for a free case review before any deadline passes.
Important exceptions and case-specific factors
Every state sets its own limitations period, tolling rules for minors, statute of repose, pre-suit affidavit or notice requirements and damages caps, and these change. Claims against public or university hospitals, military and VA facilities, and federally funded clinics follow special procedures with short deadlines. Some states limit who can bring a wrongful death claim and what it can recover. Whether any of these rules applies to your family is a question only a licensed attorney in your state can answer from the facts of your case.
- Experience: CP Family Help works exclusively with cerebral palsy, HIE, and birth-injury families across 38 U.S. states.
- Expertise to verify: The legal and medical statements on this page are sourced below; whether they apply to your child is a question for independent experts reading the records.
- Professional guidance: Confirm legal decisions with a licensed attorney in your state and medical decisions with your child’s clinicians.
- Case-specific: Deadlines, damages rules and the strength of any claim depend on the state and on the records.
High-confidence information
- ACOG classifies fetal heart rate tracings into three categories, and Category III tracings require prompt evaluation and action.
- The ACOG and AAP 2014 report lists cord blood gas, Apgar, multi-organ and MRI findings that support an acute intrapartum event.
- Therapeutic hypothermia begun within six hours of birth is the standard of care for eligible infants with moderate or severe HIE.
- Families have a federal right under HIPAA to copies of their child’s complete medical records.
Case-specific information
- Whether a particular tracing or response fell below the standard of care is a question for qualified experts reviewing the complete record.
- The meaning of an individual cord gas, Apgar score or MRI depends on the whole clinical picture.
- Record retention periods and storage of fetal monitoring data differ by hospital and state.
- Deadlines for a claim depend on the state where the baby was born.
Related reading for parents
- HIE lawyer: what an attorney investigates
- Cord blood gas and pH after HIE
- HIE MRI results explained
- Fetal heart rate monitoring categories
- Can I sue for HIE?
We help families connect with experienced birth injury attorneys. Free, confidential, no obligation.