Families considering a claim want to know two things about time: how long they have to start, and how long the case will take once it starts. The first question is urgent and answered elsewhere; see our guide to the HIE lawsuit statute of limitations. This guide answers the second, phase by phase, so that a family knows what an HIE lawyer will be doing in month one, month twelve and month thirty, and how much of it will involve them.
Months 0 to 2: intake, authorizations and the records request
The case begins with a conversation about the pregnancy, labor, delivery, NICU stay and diagnosis, and with a deadline analysis: the limitations period, any tolling for a minor, any statute of repose, any notice requirement for a public hospital. You sign HIPAA authorizations [4] and the attorney requests the complete record from every hospital involved: the prenatal chart, the fetal monitoring strips, the delivery and anesthesia records, the resuscitation record, the cooling and transfer documentation, the NICU chart, imaging and placental pathology. Hospitals have up to 30 days to respond and often need reminders. Nothing is filed yet, and nothing costs you anything.
Months 2 to 6: expert review and the decision to proceed
Once the records arrive, they are organized into a timeline and sent to independent experts: a maternal-fetal medicine specialist and a labor nurse for the strip and the response, a neonatologist for the resuscitation and cooling, a pediatric neurologist for the outcome and a neuroradiologist for the MRI. Each answers two questions in writing: did the care fall below the standard, and did that failure cause the injury? Experienced attorneys decline more HIE cases than they accept at this stage. If the experts support the case, you decide whether to go forward under a written contingency agreement. If they do not, you are told why, and you keep the records.
Months 4 to 8: pre-suit requirements and filing
Many states put a gate in front of the courthouse. Pennsylvania requires a Certificate of Merit from a qualified expert, filed with the complaint or within 60 days [1]. New Jersey requires an Affidavit of Merit from a same-specialty expert within 60 days of the defendant’s answer, extendable once [2]. The District of Columbia requires a notice of intention to sue at least 90 days before filing [3]. Other states have expert-report, pre-suit screening panel or notice rules of their own. The complaint is then filed in the court where venue is proper, naming the hospital and the providers the evidence supports, and served on each defendant, who typically has 20 to 30 days to answer.
A free, confidential review of the records can tell you whether the care met the standard, at no cost to your family.
Months 8 to 30: discovery
Discovery is the longest phase. Both sides exchange written questions and documents, and then take depositions: the labor nurses, the obstetrician, the anesthesiologist, the neonatologist, the parents, and eventually the experts on each side. The defense retains its own obstetric, neonatal and radiology experts and will argue that the injury predated labor or had another cause. In parallel, a certified life care planner evaluates the child and projects lifetime needs, and an economist converts the plan to present value; the defense does the same. Courts set these deadlines in a scheduling order, and they slip. For most families this phase means two or three days of their own time, the depositions and the life care evaluation, spread across a year or more. See our guides to the discovery process and expert witnesses.
Months 18 to 36: mediation, settlement and court approval
Once the expert reports and the life care plan are complete, the parties usually mediate: a day with a neutral mediator, the family, the attorneys and the insurers’ representatives, where most HIE cases that have survived to this point resolve. A settlement for a minor is then submitted to the court, which reviews the amount, the attorney’s fee and costs and the plan for the money, typically a structured settlement and a special needs trust that preserves Medicaid and SSI [5]. Liens from Medicaid or insurers are negotiated and paid. Funding usually follows within one to three months of approval. For what reported outcomes look like and what drives the number, see HIE lawsuits and settlements and how much an HIE case is worth.
Trial and appeal, when a case does not settle
A small share of HIE cases are tried. A trial in a birth injury case typically runs one to three weeks, with the strip, the experts and the life care plan presented to a jury; the parents testify about the delivery and the child’s daily life. Either side may appeal a verdict, which can add a year or more. Hospitals and insurers know which attorneys will try a case, and settlement values track that reputation, which is one reason to ask any attorney how many birth injury cases they have tried to verdict. Our HIE lawyer page lists the questions to ask.
Step-by-step: what families can do now
None of these steps commits you to a claim. They keep every option open while you decide.
- Write down the date and state of birth and ask for the deadline analysis first; it is the only clock that can end a case.
- Sign the HIPAA authorizations promptly and send the attorney any records, discharge summaries and imaging you already have.
- Keep a running folder of therapy evaluations, neurology notes and school plans; they become the life care plan.
- Expect two or three days of your own time over the life of the case: intake, your deposition and the mediation.
- Ask how a settlement would be structured and whether a special needs trust will be used to protect benefits.
- Ask the attorney how many birth injury cases they have tried to verdict; settlement timing and value track that answer.
- Pennsylvania – birth injury deadlines, rules and courts
- New Jersey – birth injury deadlines, rules and courts
- Washington D.C. – birth injury deadlines, rules and courts
- Texas – birth injury deadlines, rules and courts
Show 35 more statesHide extra states
- Alabama – birth injury deadlines, rules and courts
- Arizona – birth injury deadlines, rules and courts
- Arkansas – birth injury deadlines, rules and courts
- California – birth injury deadlines, rules and courts
- Colorado – birth injury deadlines, rules and courts
- Connecticut – birth injury deadlines, rules and courts
- Florida – birth injury deadlines, rules and courts
- Georgia – birth injury deadlines, rules and courts
- Illinois – birth injury deadlines, rules and courts
- Indiana – birth injury deadlines, rules and courts
- Iowa – birth injury deadlines, rules and courts
- Kentucky – birth injury deadlines, rules and courts
- Maine – birth injury deadlines, rules and courts
- Maryland – birth injury deadlines, rules and courts
- Massachusetts – birth injury deadlines, rules and courts
- Michigan – birth injury deadlines, rules and courts
- Minnesota – birth injury deadlines, rules and courts
- Mississippi – birth injury deadlines, rules and courts
- Missouri – birth injury deadlines, rules and courts
- Montana – birth injury deadlines, rules and courts
- Nebraska – birth injury deadlines, rules and courts
- Nevada – birth injury deadlines, rules and courts
- New Hampshire – birth injury deadlines, rules and courts
- New Mexico – birth injury deadlines, rules and courts
- New York – birth injury deadlines, rules and courts
- Ohio – birth injury deadlines, rules and courts
- Oklahoma – birth injury deadlines, rules and courts
- Oregon – birth injury deadlines, rules and courts
- Rhode Island – birth injury deadlines, rules and courts
- Tennessee – birth injury deadlines, rules and courts
- Vermont – birth injury deadlines, rules and courts
- Washington – birth injury deadlines, rules and courts
- West Virginia – birth injury deadlines, rules and courts
- Wisconsin – birth injury deadlines, rules and courts
- Wyoming – birth injury deadlines, rules and courts
When to act quickly
Some deadlines run from the date of birth rather than from the diagnosis, wrongful death claims are usually shorter than an injured child’s claim, claims against public hospitals often require a written notice within months, and federal facilities follow the Federal Tort Claims Act with its own two-year administrative claim. Hospitals also follow records-retention schedules, so fetal monitoring strips and nursing records are easiest to obtain while they are recent. If any of these may apply to your family, ask now rather than later.
What to bring to a case review
Bring, or be ready to request, three things: the complete prenatal, labor and delivery and NICU records including the fetal monitoring strips; a written timeline of the delivery and the first days with the names you remember; and every discharge summary, imaging report, neurology note and therapy evaluation since. If a placenta was sent to pathology, ask for that report too. You do not need to organize or interpret any of it; that is the attorney’s job.
How CP Family Help supports families
CP Family Help is not a law firm. We are an informational resource and free case-review service, sponsored by Villari, Giannone & Matteo, P.C., that helps families in 38 states and Washington, D.C. understand what may have happened and connects them with experienced birth injury trial attorneys when they want to explore a claim. Intake is available in English and Spanish, the review is free and confidential, and partner attorneys work on a written contingency agreement, so there are no upfront fees and no fee unless there is a recovery. If the records show that nothing could have been done, you will be told so plainly.
Independent experts, not the hospital, read the records. Ask for a free case review before any deadline passes.
Important exceptions and case-specific factors
Every state sets its own limitations period, tolling rules for minors, statute of repose, pre-suit affidavit or notice requirements and damages caps, and these change. Claims against public or university hospitals, military and VA facilities, and federally funded clinics follow special procedures with short deadlines. Some states limit who can bring a wrongful death claim and what it can recover. Whether any of these rules applies to your family is a question only a licensed attorney in your state can answer from the facts of your case.
- Experience: CP Family Help works exclusively with cerebral palsy, HIE, and birth-injury families across 38 U.S. states.
- Expertise to verify: The legal and medical statements on this page are sourced below; whether they apply to your child is a question for independent experts reading the records.
- Professional guidance: Confirm legal decisions with a licensed attorney in your state and medical decisions with your child’s clinicians.
- Case-specific: Deadlines, damages rules and the strength of any claim depend on the state and on the records.
High-confidence information
- Pennsylvania requires a Certificate of Merit (Pa.R.C.P. 1042.3), New Jersey an Affidavit of Merit (N.J.S.A. 2A:53A-27), and the District of Columbia a 90-day notice of intention (D.C. Code 16-2802) in medical malpractice cases.
- A settlement on behalf of a minor requires court approval, and assets in a special needs trust under 42 U.S.C. 1396p(d)(4)(A) are not counted against Medicaid and SSI eligibility.
- Families have a federal right under HIPAA to copies of their child’s complete medical records, generally within 30 days of a request.
- Nearly every state requires expert testimony to establish the standard of care in a medical malpractice case.
Case-specific information
- The length of any particular case depends on the court’s schedule, the number of defendants, the complexity of the medical issues and whether it settles or is tried.
- Pre-suit requirements and deadlines vary by state and by whether a public hospital is a defendant.
- The strength of the expert evidence and the venue affect when and whether a case settles.
- Lien amounts and structured settlement terms depend on the individual case.
Related reading for parents
- HIE lawsuit statute of limitations by state
- The discovery process in birth injury lawsuits
- Expert witnesses in birth injury lawsuits
- HIE lawsuits: settlements, verdicts and case value
- HIE lawyer: what an attorney investigates
We help families connect with experienced birth injury attorneys. Free, confidential, no obligation.